FTC Gives Ann Taylor A Pass In First 'Blog Disclosure' Investigation
from the disclose-everything dept
We expressed some serious concerns with the somewhat ambiguous FTC disclosure rules directed at blogs and new media that went into effect last year, and we’ve been waiting to see how the FTC enforces those rules. We found it odd that the FTC apparently felt that celebrities could be held to different standards. There have been some questions about different activities — for example, Viacom’s actions in trying to make authorized uploads look as if they were bootlegs certainly appears to run afoul of the rules. And, more recently, there were some concerns over the NY Times’ lack of disclosure concerning its relationship with Apple when reporting on the iPad.
However, back in February, some were wondering if retailer Ann Taylor’s offer of gift cards to bloggers who covered their new line of clothing violated the rules. Apparently, the FTC did take notice, and Michael Scott points us to the news that last month, the FTC decided to give Ann Taylor a one-time pass, though it did express some concerns about the program:
Filed Under: advertising, blogs, disclosure, ftc
Companies: ann taylor, ftc
Comments on “FTC Gives Ann Taylor A Pass In First 'Blog Disclosure' Investigation”
typo alert…
Re: Re:
typo alert…
Oops. Fixed. Thanks.
Sonnovabitch!
All the money we spend there, and we could have gotten freebies for blogging about it?!
Damn you, Ann Taylor!
Indemnity
If an advertiser tells a blogger to disclose some information and then the blogger does not do so… is the advertiser still liable?
Maybe — but if so, then all that’ll happen is that there’ll be an indemnity clause in future blogger-advertiser contracts.
Video Games
I thought this was starting to become common practice in the Video Game business. To fly reviewers to a hotel somewhere (sometimes Hawaii) to get hands on experience with a game. Does this mean that all reviewers that accept trips like that are required to disclose that in their review?
Re: Video Games
Regardless of whether the FTC requires it, I’d hope an ethical reviewer would make sure a disclosure. Wouldn’t you? It would be great if advertisers themselves disclosed these practices, but I still think it’s the reviewer’s responsibility to disclose anything that a reader might reasonably interpret as a conflict of interest.
those PDFs embedded in posts
While I think it is great mike that you post those PDF. I use Google Chrome ,, and the PDF , slows down the scroling down the page, It is annoying. Any way you could put PDF views into an “optional” pop-up window , w/o embedding into your post?
It would be helpful